Skip to content
Powerleap

Contrast training · PAPE

Contrast training: do you jump higher after a heavy set?

Contrast training pairs a heavy strength exercise with a fast, explosive exercise of the same movement – for example heavy squats, then jumps. Whether you really jump higher after the heavy set differs from person to person. With 3 jumps before and 3 jumps 4–8 minutes after, you can measure it yourself.

What is contrast training?

A heavy set – for example squats with a high load – is followed by a light, fast exercise with a similar movement pattern, such as countermovement jumps. The terms are not used consistently: one meta-analysis calls alternating set for set “complex training” and the order “all heavy exercises first, then all fast ones” “contrast training” (Cormier et al. 2020). In everyday use, the heavy set → jump pairing usually goes by contrast training. In that meta-analysis of 27 studies, both forms improved jump height over several weeks in team sports, alternating set for set slightly more.

The acute question this page is about is a different one: do you jump higher a few minutes after the heavy set than before it?

PAP and PAPE

PAP (post-activation potentiation) is the increase in a muscle’s force after a strong contraction, measured with electrically evoked twitches; it has a half-life of about 28 seconds and is mainly explained by phosphorylation of the myosin light chains (Blazevich & Babault 2019).

PAPE (post-activation performance enhancement) is the improvement in voluntary movements such as jumps that can appear several minutes after a heavy set; muscle temperature, muscle cell water content and muscle activation are at least partly involved, and its time course rarely matches that of PAP (Blazevich & Babault 2019).

The heavy set also causes fatigue. What you jump afterwards is the balance of enhancement and fatigue – it depends on load, volume, rest, type of exercise and on you (Tillin & Bishop 2009).

How long to rest after the heavy set?

Right after the set, jump performance was worse on average in the meta-analyses. Favorable were 4–9 minutes (Chen et al. 2023), 8–12 minutes (Gouvêa et al. 2013) or 7–10 minutes for muscle power in general (Wilson et al. 2013), depending on the analysis.

Meta-analysisDataFinding on rest
Chen et al. 202319 randomized trials, squat → jump0–1 min unfavorable (d = −0.33), 4–7 min most favorable (d = 0.31), 8–9 min favorable (d = 0.26); across all studies no clear effect (d = 0.09)
Gouvêa et al. 201314 studies, jumps0–3 min unfavorable (−0.25), 8–12 min favorable (0.24), 4–7 min small (0.15); all confidence intervals include 0
Wilson et al. 201332 studies, muscle power (not only jumps)7–10 min largest (0.70), 3–7 min 0.54, beyond 10 min hardly any (0.02)
Seitz & Haff 201647 studies, 1,954 participantslonger rest more effective than short rest; for jumps a small effect overall (0.29)

The numbers are standardized effect sizes, not centimeters; around 0.2 counts as a small effect. Powerleap recommends 4–8 minutes: this follows Chen et al. 2023, the newest of the four analyses, and ends within the range that was favorable there.

Why you should measure it yourself

The average of many studies says little about you. Seitz & Haff (2016) found larger effects in stronger people with more resistance-training experience, Wilson et al. (2013) much larger effects in athletes than in untrained people (0.81 vs. 0.14). The analyses even disagree on the load: Wilson et al. found moderate loads (60–84% of maximum) more effective than heavy ones (over 85%), while in Chen et al. only heavy squats produced a measurable effect. Tillin & Bishop (2009) call the evidence equivocal because study conditions differ so much.

Whether your set with your rest helps you today is therefore best shown by a comparison on yourself: same jumps, same camera, before and after.

Check it yourself: the contrast check

From version 1.0.1, Powerleap walks you through this comparison: Home → “More” → “Contrast check”. It measures with slow motion like a normal jump, and the iPhone stays in the same place the whole time.

  1. Set up

    Phone upright, hip height, about 2.5 m to the side – you fully in frame, feet and floor included.

  2. 3 baseline jumps

    Three maximal jumps. The app says “Baseline 1 of 3.” and “Baseline 2 of 3.”; the baseline is the mean of the best 2 of 3. After the third jump: “Baseline 42.3 centimeters. Now your heavy set – jump again after 4 to 8 minutes.”

  3. Your heavy set

    The app shows “Now your heavy set” – “For example 3 heavy squats. Then rest – the clock is running.” The camera is off in the meantime; the iPhone stays where it is.

  4. Rest 4–8 minutes

    A bar shows the window. At 4:00 the app says “Window open – stand in place and jump.” and starts the camera by itself, at 8:00 “Window closing – jump now.” With “Jump now” you can start earlier; your rest until the first jump after the set is shown with the result.

  5. 3 jumps after the set

    Three jumps like before, calculated like the baseline: mean of the best 2 of 3.

  6. Result in cm and %

    The app shows and announces the difference (after − baseline), for example “+2.1 cm” and “+5%”, plus a verdict: “The set helps you today”, “No clear difference” or “The set still tires you” – the last one with the advice “Next time rest longer or go lighter.”

How the contrast check calculates

PartRule
Baselinemean of the best 2 of 3 jumps before the set – like the daily value of the readiness check
Aftermean of the best 2 of 3 jumps after the set
Resultafter − baseline in cm (one decimal) and in whole percent
“The set helps you today”from +5%
“No clear difference”−5% to +4%
“The set still tires you”from −6%, with the advice “Next time rest longer or go lighter.”
Recommended window4:00–8:00 from the “Now your heavy set” screen; after that “Window over – the comparison now says less”
Doesn’t countjumps landed with bent knees or detected with low confidence, and estimates – the app says “Doesn’t count for the contrast – again.”
No resultwithout 3 counting jumps each before and after the set; the jumps stay saved

Example: baseline 40.0 cm, after 42.0 cm → +2.0 cm, +5% → “The set helps you today”. With 41.6 cm after, it would be +1.6 cm, +4% → “No clear difference”.

What a difference of 1, 2 or 3 cm means

Every measurement shows its own ±. In 24 checked ground jumps (240 fps; camera raised, on the floor, low and at hip height) it was 1.2–1.9 cm per jump, and the app’s height was within ±1.5 cm of the evaluation by hand in 22 of 24, against both take-off frames where a 2-frame range applies; the other two, filmed from 4.2 m, were 2.5 and 2.6 cm too high. Against the hand mark alone it was 16 of 24, at most 3.9 cm off (table of the check jumps). On top of that, you never jump exactly the same height twice.

For its limits Powerleap assumes a spread of about 3% from jump to jump on the same day – about 1.2 cm at 40 cm. These 3% are an assumption of the app, not a value from a study. The comparison of two means of the best 2 of 3 then varies by about 2.6% (at 2% spread by 1.75%, at 4% by 3.5%), even if the set does nothing at all. That is why the app only gives a verdict from +5% (2 cm at a 40 cm baseline) or from −6%.

In our own simulation without a real effect (200,000 checks) the app, at 3% spread, wrongly showed “The set helps you today” in about 4.5% of checks and “The set still tires you” in 1.5%; at 2–4% spread per jump it was 0.6–10% and 0.1–5% of checks. For comparison: the ± of a measurement in our check was 1.2–1.9 cm, at these jump heights (26–48 cm) about 3–7%. How often a verdict is wrong therefore depends on how consistently you jump and how good the setup and light are.

A difference of 1–2 cm is therefore within the ± of a single jump and says little on its own; from about 2 cm at a 40 cm baseline the app gives a verdict. Conversely, a real gain below about 4% gets lost in the noise: “No clear difference” does not mean “does nothing”. The history lists your checks side by side (“before → after the set”), so you can see whether a result repeats on several days.

Records and readiness

The jumps after the set are real jumps: they count as records – tagged “after contrast”. They don’t count for readiness, because the set has boosted or tired them and they would distort your baseline. The 3 baseline jumps count like any normal jump.

How fresh you are overall today is measured by the readiness check; the contrast check only measures what your heavy set does.

The contrast check describes how you respond to your set today – not medical advice and not a training plan. Powerleap is a training tool, not a medical device.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between PAP and PAPE?

PAP is a short-lived increase in force measured with electrically evoked muscle twitches; its half-life is about 28 seconds. PAPE is the improvement in real movements such as jumps, which often appears only several minutes after the heavy set. Whether PAP contributes to it at all is debated (Blazevich & Babault 2019).

How long should I rest between the heavy set and the jumps?

Right after the set, jump performance was worse on average in meta-analyses. Favorable were 4–9 minutes (Chen et al. 2023), 8–12 minutes (Gouvêa et al. 2013) or 7–10 minutes for muscle power in general (Wilson et al. 2013), depending on the analysis. Powerleap recommends 4–8 minutes and shows your actual rest with the result.

Does everyone jump higher after a heavy set?

No, not reliably. On average the acute effect (PAPE) on jump height is small (Seitz & Haff 2016), and a newer meta-analysis found no clear acute effect across all studies (Chen et al. 2023). It was larger in stronger people with more resistance-training experience and in athletes (Seitz & Haff 2016; Wilson et al. 2013); a heavy set can also mainly tire you (Tillin & Bishop 2009). This concerns the minutes after the set: as training over several weeks, complex and contrast training improved jump height in a meta-analysis (Cormier et al. 2020). Whether you benefit acutely is shown by a comparison on yourself.

What does “No clear difference” mean?

The difference is between −5% and +4%, which is within measurement noise: even with no effect at all, the comparison of two means of the best 2 of 3 varies by about 2.6%, assuming a spread of 3% per jump as the app does. A small real gain may be hidden in it – “No clear difference” does not mean “does nothing”.

Do the jumps after the set count as records?

Yes. They are real jumps and count as records, tagged “after contrast”. They don’t count for readiness, because the set has boosted or tired them; the 3 baseline jumps count there like any normal jump.

Does the contrast check cost anything?

No. The contrast check is free as well: as many checks as you like, no subscription, no ads and no account.

Sources

  1. Blazevich AJ, Babault N (2019). Post-activation Potentiation Versus Post-activation Performance Enhancement in Humans: Historical Perspective, Underlying Mechanisms, and Current Issues. Front Physiol 10:1359. doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2019.01359
  2. Chen Y, Su Q, Yang J, Li G, Zhang S, Lv Y, Yu L (2023). Effects of rest interval and training intensity on jumping performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis investigating post-activation performance enhancement. Front Physiol 14:1202789. doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2023.1202789
  3. Cormier P, Freitas TT, Rubio-Arias JÁ, Alcaraz PE (2020). Complex and Contrast Training: Does Strength and Power Training Sequence Affect Performance-Based Adaptations in Team Sports? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. J Strength Cond Res 34(5):1461–1479. doi.org/10.1519/JSC.0000000000003493
  4. Gouvêa AL, Fernandes IA, César EP, Silva WAB, Gomes PSC (2013). The effects of rest intervals on jumping performance: A meta-analysis on post-activation potentiation studies. J Sports Sci 31(5):459–467. doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2012.738924
  5. Seitz LB, Haff GG (2016). Factors Modulating Post-Activation Potentiation of Jump, Sprint, Throw, and Upper-Body Ballistic Performances: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis. Sports Med 46(2):231–240. doi.org/10.1007/s40279-015-0415-7
  6. Tillin NA, Bishop D (2009). Factors Modulating Post-Activation Potentiation and its Effect on Performance of Subsequent Explosive Activities. Sports Med 39(2):147–166. doi.org/10.2165/00007256-200939020-00004
  7. Wilson JM, Duncan NM, Marin PJ, et al. (2013). Meta-Analysis of Postactivation Potentiation and Power: Effects of Conditioning Activity, Volume, Gender, Rest Periods, and Training Status. J Strength Cond Res 27(3):854–859. doi.org/10.1519/JSC.0b013e31825c2bdb